ALEGERE MULINETA BAITCASTING
Moderatori: johnnybravo, tudor, Adelin, Sorin, Moderatori
-
Dragos Cretu
- senior
- Mesaje: 329
- Membru din: 20 Iul 2007, 18:19
- Localitate: Bucuresti
- Contact:
Tristian scrie:Ce bicicleta de 20 de milioane ne recomanzi de-acolo?
Asta cu DC-u e ca cu vibratoru, de ce sa astepti sa treaca pe curent cand poti sa pui degetul? He He He!
Tristian, DC-ul face un singur lucru, foarte important de altfel. Daca la mulinetele conventionale cu frana magnetica sau centrifugala, in momentul lanseului tamburul pleaca cu 15000-18000 rpm, DC-ul permite o viteza de plecare de peste 30000 rpm, adica dublu. Pe final de lanseu, daca esti pe setari lejere tot tre` s-o controlezi cu dejtu`. Deci dubla placere...
-
Dragos Cretu
- senior
- Mesaje: 329
- Membru din: 20 Iul 2007, 18:19
- Localitate: Bucuresti
- Contact:
Vezi ca asta e un review din 2004, altul era sistemul de punctare atunci.pintea catalin scrie:http://www.tackletour.com/reviewdaiwapixy.html
Acum nu stiu daca ar mai trece de 7.
Eu stiu, dar era mai mult o gluma... oricum, daca tot vorbim de tackletour in review-ul daiwei luna face si o comparatie cu DC-urile si cam la toate spun ca diferenta de pret e cam mare pentru caracteristici aproape identice. Seria DC recunosc, sunt mulinete bune si foarte bune dar pretul mi se pare destul de mare, iar ca remarca, restul mulinetelor shimano nu imi prea plac deloc. Sunt fan Daiwa dar nu fixist, accept si alte pareri si gusturile nu se dicuta oricum. Concluzia: n-as da atatia bani in plus pe un DC pentru practic mai nimic in plus la performante.
-
Dragos Cretu
- senior
- Mesaje: 329
- Membru din: 20 Iul 2007, 18:19
- Localitate: Bucuresti
- Contact:
Atentie Tristian...comparatia este facuta cu Shimano Calcutta TE. A si spus ca daca aducea in discutie o mulineta cu DC n-ar fi avut nici o sansa Luna. Iar acolo Luna a castigat in primul rand pretului mai mic pentru ca pe criterii distincte lucrurile au stat cam asa:
1. Casting:
The Breakdown: Luna wins. When it comes to cast control systems the Daiwa Magforce-Z feels very precise and while the Calcutta TE system is better than the Luna 300, the Luna takes the cake in all the other sizes when it comes to casting feel and ease of operation. Now if you bring the Calcutta TE DC into the mix then the DC definitely trumps the Luna.
2. Retrieving:
The Breakdown: Calcutta TE wins. The Luna like many other Daiwa offerings feels refined, and the response on the gearing is solid and instantaneous. The Calcutta still reigns supreme however with a friction free feel and powerful retrieve are still the benchmark by which other round reels are judged by.
3. Drag:
The Breakdown: Luna wins. The Luna wins by a hair in this round with a surprisingly smooth and powerful drag system. We look forward to seeing how the drag holds up over time, but out of the box the Luna’s drag is exceptional
4. Ergonomics:
The Breakdown: Tie. Luna wins on smaller sizes, while larger Calcutta TE reels win. While it is somewhat hard to compare apples to apples between the two reels the smaller Luna reels have the excellent external cast control system, and all reels have a two way clutch. The external adjustment is lost on the 300 Luna unfortunately, and the larger Calcutta reels actually feel more compact thanks to the offset gearbox.
5. Durability:
The Breakdown: Calcutta TE wins. The Calcutta proves once again why it is favored among saltwater anglers, it is just plain durable and maintains consistent performance and feel longer than other reels. That being said we expected the Calcutta TE to leave the Luna in the dust in this category, but it hardly did that. The Luna vastly improves durability in Daiwa’s traditional reels, and with proper care the Luna will last.
6. Applications:
The Breakdown: Calcutta wins. The Luna series is good for everything up to large saltwater species, so good in fact that we wish the reel was available in just one additional larger size. Kudos to Daiwa for offering all the reels in both right and left hand retrieve, but Shimano’s Calcutta TE series is just more well rounded, and there is a reel for just about every application from tossing minuscule lures with the 50 size to massive iron with the CTE700.
7. Price
The Breakdown: Luna wins. No contest here. In terms of value the Luna is a surprisingly good deal, and a whole lot of reel for just over 200 dollars. The amount of machining in this reel is impressive, and the level of refinement blows away many reels costing over 30% more.
Si, ca sa intelegi ce inseamna DC-ul uite aici un review, comparatie intre Calcutta Conquest (varianta pentru Japonia a Calcuttei TE) 101 DC si Daiwa Millionaire I`ZE Light. Deci comparatie intre o mulineta de serie si una editie limitata supertunata:
http://www.tackletour.com/reviewdcvslight.html
1. Casting:
The Breakdown: Luna wins. When it comes to cast control systems the Daiwa Magforce-Z feels very precise and while the Calcutta TE system is better than the Luna 300, the Luna takes the cake in all the other sizes when it comes to casting feel and ease of operation. Now if you bring the Calcutta TE DC into the mix then the DC definitely trumps the Luna.
2. Retrieving:
The Breakdown: Calcutta TE wins. The Luna like many other Daiwa offerings feels refined, and the response on the gearing is solid and instantaneous. The Calcutta still reigns supreme however with a friction free feel and powerful retrieve are still the benchmark by which other round reels are judged by.
3. Drag:
The Breakdown: Luna wins. The Luna wins by a hair in this round with a surprisingly smooth and powerful drag system. We look forward to seeing how the drag holds up over time, but out of the box the Luna’s drag is exceptional
4. Ergonomics:
The Breakdown: Tie. Luna wins on smaller sizes, while larger Calcutta TE reels win. While it is somewhat hard to compare apples to apples between the two reels the smaller Luna reels have the excellent external cast control system, and all reels have a two way clutch. The external adjustment is lost on the 300 Luna unfortunately, and the larger Calcutta reels actually feel more compact thanks to the offset gearbox.
5. Durability:
The Breakdown: Calcutta TE wins. The Calcutta proves once again why it is favored among saltwater anglers, it is just plain durable and maintains consistent performance and feel longer than other reels. That being said we expected the Calcutta TE to leave the Luna in the dust in this category, but it hardly did that. The Luna vastly improves durability in Daiwa’s traditional reels, and with proper care the Luna will last.
6. Applications:
The Breakdown: Calcutta wins. The Luna series is good for everything up to large saltwater species, so good in fact that we wish the reel was available in just one additional larger size. Kudos to Daiwa for offering all the reels in both right and left hand retrieve, but Shimano’s Calcutta TE series is just more well rounded, and there is a reel for just about every application from tossing minuscule lures with the 50 size to massive iron with the CTE700.
7. Price
The Breakdown: Luna wins. No contest here. In terms of value the Luna is a surprisingly good deal, and a whole lot of reel for just over 200 dollars. The amount of machining in this reel is impressive, and the level of refinement blows away many reels costing over 30% more.
Si, ca sa intelegi ce inseamna DC-ul uite aici un review, comparatie intre Calcutta Conquest (varianta pentru Japonia a Calcuttei TE) 101 DC si Daiwa Millionaire I`ZE Light. Deci comparatie intre o mulineta de serie si una editie limitata supertunata:
http://www.tackletour.com/reviewdcvslight.html
Rviewul ala e, Shimano a castigat la durabilitate dar se cam intelege pe-acolo ca e vorba de apa sarata si Luna a mai pierdut ca nu are model peste 300 care oricum e barbar, ceva mai mare e sigur tot pt mari si oceane, deci nu prea ne e in atentie. Inafara de asta repet, nu prea reprosez nimic Shimano decat cel mai tare pretul, care e ... Cam dublu si pentru noi se simte, mai ales ca nu e vorba de 50 euro. Daca traiam toti in america majoritatea aveam shimano, chiar cred asta. Acuma fiecare isi lauda puiul' pentru mine, nu este o diferenta intre cele doua decat de pret. Fir intins!
-
vali stratonov
- veteran
- Mesaje: 4640
- Membru din: 19 Sep 2006, 13:26
- Localitate: cluj-napoca
-
andrei-ovidiu
- veteran
- Mesaje: 9294
- Membru din: 06 Mai 2004, 13:08
- Localitate: Rm. Valcea
- Contact:
Daca si Daiwele s-ar invarti ca angrenajele unui "biciclete" Shimano, poate n-ar mai pacani, fasai, pocani sau haraivalistrati scrie:Bravo colegu....
Daiwa the best .....restul e can-can.
Ultima oară modificat 01 Noi 2009, 21:15 de către andrei-ovidiu, modificat 1 dată în total.